As discussed here on the Blawg, earlier this week the EEOC held a public meeting to “examine the use of leave as a reasonable accommodation.”

So, what happened? Here are the highlights . . .

The Issue

Leave can constitute a reasonable accommodation under the Americans with Disabilities Act as long as it doesn’t impose undue hardship.

That’s exactly the rub. Employer advocates often take the position that indefinite leave is unreasonable and that employers can require employees to return after a set period or be terminated. The EEOC disagrees.

That disagreement has led to some humongous settlements. In 2009, the EEOC settled a case for $6.2 million with a large retailer it alleged had an excessively rigid leave policy. Earlier this year, the EEOC settled a similar case for $3.2 million.

The Discussion

The EEOC issued a press release with its take on the session. Others weighed in as well.

In short, EEOC and employee advocates asserted that inflexible leave policies violate the ADA’s “reasonable accommodation” requirement because they don’t allow for individualized fact-specific determinations. The EEOC made it crystal clear that it intends to continue aggressively pursuing “pattern and practice” cases against employers who enforce such policies.

Employer advocates agreed that leave may be a reasonable accommodation but vigorously questioned the burden the EEOC’s position puts on employers (especially small businesses). One advocate called for the EEOC to provide “more detailed and defined examples of situations where maximum leave policies are called into question and provide examples of times when additional leave will be deemed necessary and when it will not.”

What’s Next?

The EEOC announced that it will accept additional written comments on this issue through June 23.

Want to express yourself? You can email your comments to Commissionmeetingcomments@eeoc.gov or mail ‘em to:

Commission Meeting
EEOC Executive Officer
131 M Street, N.E.
Washington, D.C. 20507

The EEOC plans to issue its official written guidance on this subject in a few months. So, speak now or forever hold your peace.

Want More?

Additional info about this meeting, including a video of the proceedings and written witness statements is available here.